Sunday, March 10, 2019

Genesis Series: The Spirit of God (Ruach ha'Elohim)

In a beginning, God had created the form Heaven and the form Earth.  And when Earth was an astonishing-desert with darkness over a face of abyss, and the Spirit of God oscillating over the face of the waters: (My Translation)
Does the the 'Ruwach' refer to an Object or to a Concept?

In the Christian tradition, the Hebrew ruwach is translated as Spirit (capital 'S' with a definite article 'the') in the Gen 1:2 context. And this is my translation. I note that the sacred author did not mark the word 'ruwach' with a definite article and this seems to imply that he did not quite understand what he saw. Regardless he described what he saw and this is traced as "a Spirit of God" or " a Divine Spirit."

I assume the sacred author experienced a prophecy stimulated by God. And then he described what he saw. He described objects and dynamic relations mediated by objects. Some of these objects were Divine and some of the phenomena were miraculous (or supernatural). He saw the form of the Earth as if from orbit. And later he traced a basic description of her facial features: astonishing-desert, abyss and the waters. He described Earth's surface and surroundings as dark. And he traced a contrast to the darkness described in the words 'a Spirit of God moving'. This Spirit of God was moving in direct relation to the Earth.

The first issue to resolve is whether or not this Spirit refers to an object or to a concept. Did the sacred author see an object, with a prophetically visible form that he could distinguish? My answer is an unequivocal yes. Why? Because the sacred author describes this Spirit of God performing an action: the Spirit was moving or was moved . . . in relation to Earth's surface. One can only apply motion to objects of existence. If the Spirit of God referred to a concept the sacred author would have traced nonsense since motion does not apply to concepts. Concepts (a relation of two or more objects worked out by the brain) do not move. Motion does not move.  The sacred author did not irrationally convert a concept into an object. Some assume the sacred authors and the God who inspired them uttered and traced nonsense in these most crucial of contexts but I am not one of them. 


The sacred author described an object using the Hebrew name 'ruwach'. This word basically refers to an object effused from a source object.  Here object is defined as that which has form. Sometimes it is translated as breath which is air (object) moving out of the lungs (objects). 


Now it is left for us to resolve what type of object this mysterious spirit may be.  The sacred author qualifies the Spirit with the genitive noun form: God. This object has an intimate relation with God. By virtue of the genitive form this Spirit belongs to God or better yet originates in God. The Spirit is an object emitted from God who is in Heaven down to the Earth. The Spirit is the Mediator between the two objects God and Earth.

And this is why I think the author decided to label this object as Spirit. He saw that an object was emitted from God in Heaven to the Earth. Spirit in this context refers to an object streaming forth from God. Spirit resolves to an object that the sacred author saw in his vision. Little did the sacred author know that this effused object would be recognized by Christians as the Holy Spirit.


The Interpretation of Christians

For this context most Christians in history have interpreted this word to refer to the Third Divine Object who the First Divine Object and Second Divine Object eternally generate in a singular relation that defies reason and rationale. The Trinitarian relations are inconceivable and impossible to reason alone. The Third Divine Presence labelled 'Holy Spirit' eternally proceeds from the Father and the Son. This singular Divine relation is applied to mediate miraculous Divine phenomena such as the light event of Genesis 1. From Heaven, the Father and the Son send forth the Spirit to the Earth similar to how the Spirit eternally proceeds from the Father and the Son.  The sacred author understood that this object was streaming forth from God in Heaven to the Earth without yet understanding that this object was a Personal Identity of the Trinity. Saint John Paul II explains this well.


Even though in the light of the texts of Isaiah the salvific work of the Messiah, the Servant of the Lord, includes the action of the Spirit which is carried out through himself, nevertheless in the Old Testament context there is no suggestion of a distinction of subjects, or of the Divine Persons as they subsist in the mystery of the Trinity, and as they are later revealed in the New Testament. Both in Isaiah and in the whole of the Old Testament the personality of the Holy Spirit is completely hidden: in the revelation of the one God, as also in the foretelling of the future Messiah. (Dominum et Vivificantem, n. 17)
The sacred author did not realize that this Divine Object he saw was a Divine Personal Identity. But he understood that what he saw was from God and of God and modified the label as such: of God: ruwach ha'Elohim.  And I assume that the sacred author saw the miraculous appearance of the Spirit for the purposes of relating events to all Mankind.

So now all that is left is to speculate on why God emitted the Spirit . . . how the Spirit miraculously appeared to the sacred author in the vision . . . and why he may have appeared that way? What Divine concept was conveyed to us via the prophetic experience and tracing of the sacred author? You might be surprised at the simplicity of what I have come up with. But you should not be. A hint has always been traced in the third verse command: Let light happen.  But before we delve into the above questions I would like to correct some associations in context to Genesis 1:2.

The Myth Mongers


From the appearance of Christ Jesus to the present Christians have understood that the Spirit described by the sacred author in this Gen 1:2 context refers to the Third Divine Person of the Holy Trinity. The Spirit proceeds (springs up) from the Father and the Son (Nicene Creed). And consistent with the One Divine Eternal Generation He is emitted to mediate Divine Acts. The Christian association is indisputable, and I could run a pretty long list of references but this will only waste internet space. With the Christian interpretation came the capitalization of the word 'Spirit' with a definite article "the" in reference to His Divine Majesty. The understanding of the Sacred Script has evolved with the coming of Christ Jesus. Jesus opened the Scriptures to his followers.

Suffice it to say that the modern myth mongers propose a 'mighty wind' or a 'divine wind' translation which challenges the traditional interpretation. In Faith, there is no rationale or justification for the translation and interpretation of 'a mighty wind'. The rational translations provide for Spirit of God as do the faith inspired translations.

The 'mighty wind' translation stems from the scholar's romance with the Ancient Near East myths. They were so convinced of a correlation between Genesis 1 and Enuma Elish or some other myth that they took it upon themselves to irrationally manipulate words. Wind is a dynamic concept relating physical objects namely air in two or more locations parallel to the Earth's surface. You cannot move wind. By conception and definition wind is moving air in relation to Earth or some object on Earth. Whoever first conceived of 'wind' in whatever language associated something moving parallel to the Earth's surface. They conceptualized to understand invisible air colliding with objects (like trees) parallel to the Earth's surface. Wind is by definition atoms moving parallel to the surface of the Earth. Wind is a superverb with the subject air, built into the verb to move or rush. Thus their translation and interpretation critically fails in contextual grammar. "mighty wind moving over a surface" is a superfluous contradiction. You cannot move concepts. You cannot move motion.  To move wind is to irrationally convert a concept into an object.

Spirit of God refers to a Divine object that the sacred author saw moving over the Earth's surface and mediated the Divine phenomena. This object was clarified by Christ Jesus and His Church as the Third Divine Object of the Trinity. The Spirit of Christ was moving over the surface of the Earth in view of Christ Jesus. The Holy Spirit is a Divine Object who performs actions. Concepts conceived of by Man such as wind do not perform actions. Objects, whether Divine, angelic, spiritual (as in the soul) or physical impart causal actions.

The myth scholars are addicted to syntactical grammar and myths, when they should assume Faith and apply contextual grammar. Sentences in linguistic grammars are context-sensitive and thus have two stages of grammatical verification: syntax and context. Once we verify that the syntax conforms to the syntactical rules of grammar, we ascribe meaning to the sentence using the analytical phase of contextual grammar. 'Mighty wind' or 'divine wind' moved over the surface of the Earth fails in the analytical phase of contextual grammar. And it fails in a Faith analysis.

And more, wind has no source object. From what source object does the wind come from? Do angels blow the wind out of their mouths? Wind is a conceptual embodiment or invocation of two or more locations of gaseous atoms parallel the internal structure of the Earth. Atoms of the outer layers move and interact with the atoms of structures built up from the crust. That is the action labelled wind. The myth mongers use of wind defies the fact that Spirit originates in God.  There is no source of wind. It is a concept: a relation of two or more objects. Concepts have no source. They are conceptualized by Man via neurons banking memories of objects.

The mythic manipulation of Genesis 1 is ridiculous. It is a terrible experience to witness the 'mighty wind' or 'divine wind' translation and interpretations among scholars with assumed authority.


Answers to Questions

My Translation of Genesis 1:1-2

In a beginning, God had created the form of Heaven and the form of Earth, and when Earth existed as an astonishing-desert with darkness over a face of abyss, and the Spirit of God oscillating over the face of the waters.
I am of the opinion that Genesis 1 is a Sacred Text based on a prophecy. I assume that this Sacred Script is based off of a vision God mediated to a holy ancient (perhaps Job, Moses, or Solomon in his height of holiness and wisdom). I raised some questions above such as

How did the Spirit appear to the sacred author in the miraculous vision?
Why did the Spirit appear the way He did?
What Divine concept was conveyed to us via the vision and tracing of the sacred author?

I will answer these questions in an interpretive theory and this will lead me into an interpretation of the Hebrew word merahepet.

Supernatural Event

Before I attempt to answer these questions I want to call to mind that in the Sacred Scripts an emission of the Spirit accompanies supernatural events. In context of Divine Revelation, supernatural refers to a concept that God performs that which is genuinely impossible, inconceivable, suprarational, extraordinary to the brain. A genuine miracle worked by God cannot be scientifically explained, or formally validated using petty logic. My God is a God of genuine miracles. God does that which is impossible in terms of Mother Nature.

When God sends the Spirit to an object such as Jesus, or Mary, or the young Church gathered together in the Upper Room, a supernatural phenomenon occurs. The Father does not send the Spirit on a whim, right? Nor does He send the Spirit to merely overlook or guide natural processes, right? Angels can administer providence. The sending forth of the Spirit is an extraordinary favor that usually induces a supernatural event, right? God is a God of miracles, right? We do not need P.H.D.'s or letters behind our names to figure this out . . . right?

Examples of the Spirit described as mediating a supernatural phenomenon in the Sacred Script should be obvious to any Christian. It is important that I at least given one example since this argument underlies my interpretation of Genesis 1. Lets take the Incarnation for an example:

From the Gospel of Matthew: After his mother Mary had been betrothed to Joseph, before they lived together, she was found to have conceived in her womb by the Holy Spirit.
From the Gospel of Luke: And in response, the Angel said to her: “The Holy Spirit will pass over you, and the power of the Most High will overshadow you. And because of this also, the Holy One who will be born of you shall be called the Son of God. 
Description from the visions of Blessed Anne: The ceiling of the room vanished, and over the house appeared a luminous cloud with a pathway of light leading up from it to the opened heaven. Far up in the source of this light, I beheld a vision of the Most Holy Trinity. It was like a triangle of glory, and I thought that I saw therein the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost. As Mary uttered the words: "May it be done unto me according to thy word!" I saw an apparition [appearance] of the Holy Ghost. The countenance was human and the whole apparition surrounded by dazzling splendor, as if surrounded by wings. From the breast and hands, I saw issuing three streams of light. They penetrated the right side of the Blessed Virgin and united into one under her heart. . . She, entirely absorbed in self, saw in herself the Incarnate Son of God, a tiny, human form of light with all the members, even to the little fingers perfect. It was about midnight that I saw this mystery.
There are also the examples of the Baptism of Jesus and Pentecost. There are also some examples of Old Testament prophets or kings induced to perform some extraordinary action via the Spirit.

It is no different in the event described in Genesis 1. The Spirit is sent to mediate a supernatural event that is unique in the history of the Universe. Anyone who attempts to interpret the events of Genesis 1 as natural physical processes has overlooked the formidable presence of the Spirit of God in this Text. When the Spirit is present, a unique supernatural event takes place. Do you really think that the sacred author just inserted a description of the Spirit of God as a little side note? I do not. I think He saw a significant apparition of the Spirit and prophetically witnessed a stupendous miracle unlike any other in history of the Universe.

Law of Causality Applied to Frame the Context

The Spirit was sent to Personally mediate (impart causal actions) to the target Earth. The causal actions are miraculous, done at the Divine Will. Earth's face changes as the Spirit imparts a miraculous stimulation. The output of the events is a transfigured Earth orbiting the Sun with living objects on its surface including Adam and Eve. At event-consummation, the seventh day, God retires from His miraculous work.

I suppose that the Earth was an old dark star moving in our galaxy close to the newer Sun, but not yet locked into a gravitational relation (inverse square regime, orbit). When the Spirit was sent to the Earth, Earth was located between stars or interstellar space as we say. I suppose that God moved Heaven near to the Earth and emitted the Spirit to the Earth, thus establishing a singular connection between God and the Earth. God locked Himself into a relationship with the Earth via the Spirit, and the Spirit mediated God's Desires in view of Christ Jesus. The Spirit effectively changes the face of the Earth in a course of miraculous events that are traced by the sacred author in the Genesis 1 narrative.

The sacred author was privy to God's conceptualization and choices.  And he saw the miraculous 'change effects' of the Earth's face imparted by the Spirit in the duration of the light event. Genesis 1 is not a narrative of the Universe's creation ex nihilo. It is rather a narrative of the Earth's change or her transformation.  I call it the light-event. This is a unique supernatural phenomenon. The Mediators of the light event are the Father, the Son, and the missive Spirit. The target object is the Earth. At the light event's consummation there is an output that is a transfigured Earth orbiting the Sun with a new atmosphere, and living objects on the surface including Adam and Eve. The Moon (another old dark star) is also brought into a locked gravitational system with the Earth.

Let me restate this again. I assume that the Earth was a naturally transformed star or rogue planet peacefully moving around the galactic core. Its time is inestimable. It could have existed for tens of billions of years prior to the light event described in Genesis 1:3. At some juncture of the past, after the fall of some angels, God moves Heaven close to the Earth, sends the Spirit to the Earth and changes her.

The missive Spirit of God imparted a supernatural causal action to the Earth's surface, effectively changing her face and guiding her into a locked orbit around the Sun all in accord with the Divine commands related in Genesis 1. There is nothing natural about my interpretation. God defies Mother Nature.

Before moving on let me summarize the context using Aristotle's Law of Causality:

Aristotle’s Law of Causality is stated as follows:

A Mediator or Mediators (object A) impart causal action to a Target (object B)

The Law of Causality was originally meant to be applied to physical objects but I will slightly modify for my context. In this context object A is God: the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. So we will label object A as A1, A2, A3. This context is unique since the Spirit (object A3) is emitted from the Father (object A1) and the Son (object A2) in Heaven to the Earth, thus establishing a supernatural connection so as to miraculously interact with the Earth. The Spirit (A3) mediates the chosen concepts of the Father and the Son (object A1 and object A2). Object B is the Earth, specifically her surface as it was sometime in the past, perhaps billions of years ago and prior to the appearance of life and moving between stars.

Its specific application in the context of the Light-Event (or Transfiguration of the Earth) could be stated as follows:

Mediators (object A1, A2, A3) impart causal action to a Target (object B). At event consummation, there is a resulting Output (object C)

Object C is the changed Earth. Her appearance is transfigured with the additions of a new atmosphere, defined landmasses, defined oceans, and living objects moving on their own on Earth's surface in spite of gravity. The event consummation is described by the sacred author in his seventh day.

The concepts pertaining to the Light-Event are:

Cause: The “act” of miraculously imparting action with the Earth (object B) as performed by God (object A1, A2, A3).

Effect: The “change” realized by the Earth (object B) during the duration of the “causal action” imparted by God (object A1, A2, A3). .

Light-Event: The phenomenon of transfiguration from initiation of transfiguration (Let light happen), to termination of transfiguration described as God blessing his work and ceasing from his work. An event is always consummated. The sacred author clearly understood this.

The actors participating in the Light-Event are:

Object A: The Mediator object (Father A1, Son A2, and Spirit A3) imparting “causal action”.
Object B: The Target object (the Earth) undergoing “change effect”.
Object C: The Output object (transfigured Earth) resulting from the consummated event.

Remember “Cause” and “effect” are verbs. They resolve to concepts conceived by Aristotle or some other Greek. Concepts do not refer to objects. A concept invokes or embodies two or more objects (that which has form). There is no such thing as ‘a’ cause or ‘an’ event; ‘a’ cause or ‘an’ event does not exist. Only objects, like God and the Earth exist.  Cause is a concept that refers to what object A (God) does to object B (Earth). Effect is a concept that refers to the “change” realized by object B (Earth) during the duration of the “causal action” imparted by object A (God). An event is a specific phenomenon from the initiation of the phenomenon to the consummation of the phenomenon. A phenomenon is a dynamic relation of objects mediated by objects.

Light Event:

1) At light-event initiation, the Mediator (A3, or the Spirit) moves toward the Target object (the Earth) and imparts a miraculous interaction with the Earth in accord with A1 and A2's command.

2) At this stage, the Spirit has imparted “causal action” to the Target object.

3) Simultaneously with 2, “change effect” is realized by the Target object while supernaturally interacting with the Mediator, specifically A3.

4) At light-event termination, the phenomenon is formally termed: Consummated Event

The Spirit Appeared to the Sacred Prophet as a Ray extending from the Heaven to the Earth


The Spirit of God changed the Earth. He is the intervening object between God and the Earth. The Father and the Son also impart supernatural causal action to the Earth, since God always acts as One, but they do this by way of the Spirit which they emitted. The sacred prophet must have seen something in his vision, otherwise how could he have described a Spirit of God moving over the Earth's surface waters? So my question is just how did the Spirit appear to the sacred author in the dynamic of the prophecy?

The sending forth of the Spirit is rooted in God's decision: Let light happen. The Divine word concept 'Let light happen' has a superficial meaning as well as a deeper meaning. The superficial meaning is that God literally lit up the surface of the Earth in the work of this event. God literally stimulated the entire surface of the cold dark Earth and in this her atoms tapped into the subatomic objects which mediate light at higher frequencies. If there was an observer in orbit he would register the change of colors.

The deeper meaning is that God locks Himself into a dynamic relationship with the Earth so as to induce Her transfiguration. Light is a phenomenon. A phenomenon is a dynamic relation of objects mediated by a connected object(s). In the case of light phenomena, atoms stimulate atoms via subatomic objects which interconnect all hydrogen atoms (or protons and neutrons of the Universe) in addition to serving so as to impart form to them all. This invisible physical mediator connecting all atoms has a form like a double twined thread and has unique properties. But the important point to take from this assumption is that all that atoms of the Universe are connected by this fundamental subatomic object, these invisible rays.

In Genesis 1 the Spirit is the 'oscillating mediator'. The sacred prophet saw the Spirit appear as if an oscillating ray extending from God in Heaven down to the Earth. Now this might sound ridiculous but it is consistent with the command "Let light happen" as well as the prophetic experiences given to other Saints. In Blessed Anne's description of the light-event Blessed Anne said she saw a beam of light:

While these changes were going on upon the dark globe, I saw, as it were, a streaming forth of light out of that highest of all the spheres, the Godsphere, that sphere in which God dwelt. (Mysteries of the Old Testament)
In other words she saw a beam of light extend from Heaven to the Earth with the caveat, 'as it were'. The stream of light was not a physical phenomenon rather representative of a Divine phenomenon, namely the Spirit sent from God and imparting causal action to the Earth.

Theopholus of Antioch, a second century Church Father interprets the Spirit as 'holding the place of light' between Heaven and the waters of Earth's surface:

For the Spirit being one, and holding the place of light, was between the water and the Heaven, (Theophilus ad Autolycus, Genesis Commentary)
It is as if the Holy Spirit is a Ray of Light in the vision. This is significant, because the set of objects that mediate light between, or to and from all the atoms of the Universe, literally connects them all, and more all atoms assume their form from these invisible subatomic objects. So, the Spirit of God appearing as a Ray of Light in the vision shows that God is making a singular connection with the Earth.  No other astronomical object gets this sort of treatment.

The sacred author/prophet saw this beam of light so as to relay the mediation of the Spirit to us in words. The Spirit appeared as an extending ray of light from God in Heaven to the Earth. The symbolism is clear. The Spirit is a Mediator who connects the Earth to God in Heaven and stimulates the Earth. God mediates a supernatural work to the Earth's surface via the Spirit similar to an active-fusing star working the surface of a dark inactive star (a planet) via their EM radiation. God conceived of his miracle based on His previous works of the Universe namely the creation of atoms with their fundamental subatomic objects, and the formation of stars and their interrelations with other stars in a system.


The Hebrew Merahepet

Merahepet (transliterated) is the Hebrew action word assigned to the Spirit of God. The form of the word is a Pi'el singular participle of the verb root rahap. I assume rahap refers to a concept meaning to move back and forth or to and from. All verbs are a manner of motion. Like the Hebrew tohu wabohu this word is extremely rare (used only one other time in the Bible) and could be used as another argument that this Text is based off of a prophecy. The sacred author clearly wrote about extraordinary events and circumstances that could be described using rare words. How did he conceive of these events? God mediated a prophetic experience in the sacred author's brain.

Some have the Pi'el participle translated as 'hovering'. This translation is derived from usage of the verb 'rahap' in the Book of Deuteronomy 32:11 where the LORD is figuratively described as an eagle that moves over its young. A variation of this concept is 'fluttering'. The problem with this translation is that the Spirit of God is not figuratively described as a bird in the Genesis 1 context. It doesn't seem consistent with the Text that the sacred author visualized the Spirit of God hovering or fluttering over an entire planet in an eagle like apparition. So an analogous translation of the Pi'el rahap should be discarded for this context.

Other choose a more conservative translation such as 'the Spirit of God moved over', etc., etc. or 'the Spirit of God was brought over' etc., etc. Latin tradition). These translations are generic. All verbs are a manner of motion.  The root of merahepet could have been conceptualized from understanding a mother bird in relation to its young, or it could have been conceptualized by understanding another natural phenomena. Or perhaps the sacred author of Genesis 1 conceived of the concept signaled in the trace of the new verb merahepet via his prophetic experience! He saw an object appear to move back and forth on Earth's surface. In this context merahepet refers to a prophetic conceptualization of the movement of the Holy Spirit. The sacred author experienced a prophetic dream and conceived of his own concepts signaled by new words such as tohu wabohu and merahepet.

Merahepet could simply refer to a bi-directional motion such as the move alternatively back and forth. Perhaps the author of Deuteronomy adopted this verb from Genesis 1 so as to describe the motion of an eagle. The Hebrew interlinear CHES 2.0 version has merahepet translated as 'vibrating'.

I have the merahepet translated as 'oscillating' since I suppose the sacred author envisioned a ray of light emanating from God in Heaven to the Earth. This beam could have appeared to be oscillating between God in Heaven and the Earth. And of course I have already explained that this oscillating ray refers to an apparition of the Spirit and his causal action.

Another interesting note is that the verb is in a Hebrew Pi'el form. This form is interesting, as if it were tailor made for Trinitarian relations. Here is an excerpt taken from Jones:

. . .[Pi'el] indicates bringing about a state. Hebrew uses the Piel when the subject is putting the object into the state or condition corresponding to the meaning of the verb root. The object thus takes part in the action as a passive, secondary subject. Being a state, the action tends to be habitual or ongoing. ***
In terms of the linguistic form of the Hebrew Pi'el, the Father and the Son are the subjects, and the Spirit is the object. The Father and the Son are putting the Spirit into the continuous state of 'oscillating' over the Earth's surface. This is representative of the Spirit's causal action: a supernatural relation that stimulates Earth, changes her and puts out new forms, e.g. living objects. And the Spirit as a passive secondary subject takes part in the action. So in other words the Spirit moved toward the Earth on His own. The Spirit participates in His motion since the Three Persons act as One. The Spirit is a Mediator, A3 (as in above). He actively imparts causal action and this work is One with the Father and the Son who it is assumed in the narrative to have sent the Spirit and communicate 'commands' to the extended Spirit. The Hebrew Piel is custom-made by Divine Providence to communicate to the Holy Spirit’s Mission.

*** Jones, Scott Walker (2003) Hebrew for Biblical Interpretation, Society of Biblical Literature, p. 133

Thursday, March 7, 2019

Genesis Series: Tehom (Abyss) of Genesis 1:2

In a beginning, God had created the form Heaven and the form Earth,
And when Earth existed as an astonishing-desert with darkness over a face of abyss
The translations of the Gen 1:2 tehom are not that varied:

ocean, abyss, the deep, deep waters, the watery deep.

For the Gen 1:2 context some choose to modify with primeval, so primeval ocean, etc.

The sacred author has abyss associated with the mayim, the Hebrew plural word translated as waters in the subsequent parallel phrase. Tehom is connected to mayim.

Abyss---waters.

The prominent linguistic work analyzing some of the Hebrew words of Gen 1:2 is David Toshio Tsumura's The Earth and the Waters in Genesis 1 and 2. Tsumura analyses the word 'tehom' from many different angles and comes to the rational conclusion that it is not a mythic personification:

This Hebrew term tehom is simply a reflection of the Common Semitic term *tiham- "ocean" and there is no relation between the Genesis account and the so-called Chaoskampf mythology. (p. 65)
Another scholar, Roberto Ouro has some interesting notes:
The term tehom appears 36 times in the OT, in singular and in plural. This Hebrew term appears without an article in all texts but Isa 63:13 (singular) and Ps 106:9 (plural). Tehom always means a flood of water or ocean (abyss); there is no type of personification. The word appears in a context of creation" with no mythical reference. The word is used to designate a phenomenon of nature.  Many times tehom is parallel to mayim "water" or yam "sea". (THE EARTH OF GENESIS 1:2 ABIOTIC OR CHAOTIC? PART II, p. 47 see his excellent article here)
What I found interesting in Ouro is that the Hebrew word is not prefaced by an article. Thus it may refer to an undefined concept, not an object. The word is used to describe Earth's surface. The sacred author is not pointing to an object, he is rather describing an object, the Earth, with a concept 'abyss'. So I translate 'face of abyss' instead of 'face of THE abyss'. The Hebrew "tehom" is a concept that refers to a vast supply or gathering of water covering the Earth. It doesn't matter if the supply rests over the crust or is enclosed in the crust. It could be both.  Tehom simply refers to water supply or gathering of waters. Tehom is first and foremost a physical concept. And this is indisputable for this context.

It is intriguing since later in the narrative God organizes the waters into defined Seas implying that the surface of abyss is stimulated and broken up by the land perhaps from below. So there is a dynamic physical process described in the advance of the narrative that needs to be decoded by the reader and this corresponds to God working miracles. Otherwise the narrative would make no sense. Unfortunately some interpreters try to make sense of the narrative by reading myths, scientific theories such as Big-Bang or the creation and history of the angels.

In other contexts of Sacred Scripture 'tehom' takes on different references. It could be figured to refer to Hell. The sacred authors also use this word to refer to the event of the Great Flood. But that is a different context. I've spent many articles establishing the context I think the sacred author refers to based on a prophetic vision. Truly, the one of the biggest interpretive battles of Genesis One is establishing the context of the subject of the second verse: the Earth.

In Gen 1:2 'tehom' is used to describe the surface of an astronomical object that the sacred author saw in a vision induced by God. "darkness over a face of abyss" adds additional information and modification to the subject of the sentence, i.e. Earth. The Earth is first described as tohu wabohu then as a subset is described "with darkness over a face of abyss". The face is Earth's face, Earth's surface, not another object's surface, certainly not the surface of a concept since concepts have no form!!!

Assume that the face description refers to Earth's face and abyss is a facial feature. An analogy would be an eye with a surface of tears. The context gets confused if the subject of the sentence is not assumed as an astronomical object that the sacred author visualized as if face to face. The sacred author looks at the Earth which faces him as if with eyes looking at him.  The sacred author first describes that entire object is an astonishing-desert then he describes her face as dark and yet with a water supply. These are physical concepts since they are used in context to a physical object: the Earth. The observation of the sacred author was made possible by God who stimulated a prophetic experience in the brain of the sacred author.  The seeming contradiction of astonishing desert (tohu wabohu) with abyss and waters is that Earth's surface was cold in interstellar space.

Connection of the word 'tehom' to the mythical Tiamat or Chaos is a romantic fancy of scholars who are in the heat of love with the myths. They can love the myths all they want but they should not read them into Genesis 1, 2, & 3 which a Jew and Christian read with Faith. This is irrational and childish. God and the sacred author were oblivious in relation to the Ancient Near East myths. The sacred author was not influenced by the myths. He was influenced by God and his miracles. He was influenced by the prophetic 3D movie God worked in his brain.


Abyss Theory

T
he Earth was covered with a water supply mingled with various molecules and chemicals. The sacred author did not need to be aware or knowledgeable of all the chemicals since he relates a basic description of the surface and events. He identified water, since water is of course essential to living entities. There was a surface ocean. It was froze over and appeared as if a super dry barren desert much like one could describe Antarctica as a desert.

Where did the Earth's water come from? My personal belief is that the Earth synthesized H2O in her transformation from a young active-fusing phase. Earth is a cinder of what was once a star. After she left her fusion phase and shed zillions of atoms; she became less energetic and atoms vibrated less (she cooled).  In the process she synthesized molecules, chemicals, crystals, and so on from her atomic elements.  And she continued to compress. She was a chemical factory. At some time hydrogen and oxygen molecules in the outer layers of the Earth were stimulated [induced to pump and vibrate and spin, etc] by the atoms of the core at the right frequencies and amps so as to arrange to an abundance of the H2O compound. The spark of energy needed to form the waters came from within. Most of our water very well may have been homegrown and then held in snug via gravitational attraction and pressure. The synthesized waters may have helped the crust to form. Perhaps some planets of our system are synthesizing waters in a phase leading into a water-world, even as we speak.

If my personal belief is not right then perhaps Earth was a rogue planet.  In any case I also suppose that the Earth assimilated some water and chemicals in her march around the galaxy.  She may have assimilated some H2O through interstellar clouds or even accretion disks of newer stars like TW Hydrae.  Maybe that is why she has just a trace of heavier water (called D2O, deuterium oxide, where the Hydrogen atoms are deuterium 1 proton and 1 neutron). The theory that Earth assimilated her water supply from comets is irrational since the comets are observed to have D2O not H2O. Other than this the scientific establishment has no theory of the origin of Earth's water supply since their assumptions are limited by the scope of the ad hoc bloated and irrational nebular hypothesis.

Back to Earth's water supply. She has just a trace of D2O. She probably passed through some dense interstellar clouds through which she assumed some rare atomic elements, molecules and chemicals. Passages through interstellar clouds diversified her makeup and supplied her with rare atomic elements not able to be homemade e.g. uranium. Earth had a long journey prior to her meeting with the Spirit of God!

Just prior to the light-event, Earth's water supply was more or less froze over since the Earth was very old, and moving between stars (not locked into a system with another star). So she was an old dark star with a froze over water supply, a buried crust, a mantle and a core (she was differentiated). The surface of the Earth was, as it were, asleep. Her skin (outer layer) was shivering in interstellar space. There was no chaos happening at the surface and little or no atmosphere. Earth's surface was quiet; awaiting the miraculous stimulation worked by God via the Spirit. The water supply was mixed with a variety of chemicals such as methane, ammonia, CO2 (dry ice), carbon monoxide and other volatiles. This interpretive theory would give some credence to Sasson's hodgepodge translation of tohu wabohu. Her surface was a hodgepodge of chemicals. Underneath the frozen shell were subsurface oceans. In the vision the surface appeared to the sacred author as a vast super-desert and he was astonished. But in retrospect he knew that there were surface and subsurface waters since he saw the forming of the first Seas.

The Spirit stimulated the surface; kicked up the surface/subsurface waters and chemicals in stylish bands, did some reactions and stretched out the molecules all the way around the Earth in every direction so as to envelop her with a first modern atmosphere. From the locations where He kicked up the pillars he formed the lands. Once the crust miraculously appears up from beneath the waters the remaining surface waters were gathered to form primitive Seas. These Seas were soon inhabited by a pristine first generation of aquatic animals which God miraculously formed.  This is why God and the sacred author use two different concepts to describe the Earth's waters: abyss and later in the narrative (verse 10) ... Seas.  There is progress.  

Thursday, February 28, 2019

Genesis Series: The Word Face in Genesis 1


You sent forth your Spirit, a
nd they were created, and you renewed the face of the Earth. (Psalm 103)

The word 'face' is a fairly simple concept taken from antiquity. This word is used a great many times in the Bible e.g. face of the Earth, face of the sky, face of wind, etc. In the Hebrew it is a plural word which some have pointed out suggests the many motions and changes of the human face.


Face refers to the front of the head, that location from which the eyes are directed. The ancients transferred the concept 'face' to pretty much anything even God. When this concept is used figuratively an observer substitutes his eyes with the plane of the object in question. It is as if objects have a face with eyes and are looking the observer in the face. So it is as if the Earth has a face with eyes looking at you when you are aligned with plane of the Earth. Strictly speaking this is only possible from outer space but it can also be envisioned from a mountain top over looking a plain.

Now take the Man on the Moon as an example. We face the full Moon and imagine it to have eyes and a mouth on its plane. Face of the Moon, face of the Earth, face of the wind, etc. is a subjective, self-referential notion. It's use implies an observer projecting an imaginary set of eyes on the plane of the object in question. You look at the object and imagine the plane of that object to have eyes looking at you or at something else. Perhaps later this notion degenerated to reference the literal plain concept of a surface but the above is, I think, something of the original notion that dates to antiquity.

So now take the second verse of Genesis One. The sacred author describes the Earth as if some features of its plane were looking at him:

And when the Earth existed as an astonishing-desert with darkness over a face of an abyss, and the Spirit of God oscillating over the face of the waters . . .
The sacred author describes facial features of the Earth. His use of the word 'face' suggests to me that he had a bird's eye view of the Earth and that Genesis One is a prophecy. How else could he write with any sort of intellectual honesty?  This view was made possible by God who stimulated a prophetic experience in the brain of the sacred author. The sacred author was not really present way back when the Earth existed like an astonishing wasteland with a water supply prior to the moment when God changed it in the light-event; but he was able to see this Earth because of the vision that God induced in his brain.

The sacred author was induced to look at the Earth from afar as if from a vantage point in outer space. This is how he is able to describe this object as an astonishing-desert with some sort of aquatic facial features. As if the waters, or whatever primitive ocean existed was looking at him placed beyond in outer space with the imaginary eyes he substitutes on its plain.  At first the sacred author is seeing the Earth from the vantage of a satellite or spaceship. And what did he see? His description is basic. He saw a dark and barren astronomical object standing out before him, with no life or living entities.  He also knew of a water supply and the Spirit of God hovering over the surface.  


This is simple stuff, the difficulty lies in establishing a reasonable and correct context.  By doing this we do not stray by reading all sorts of ridiculous myths, matter, space, time, universe, Hell, fallen angels, photons, cosmic microwave background, etc. into the first and second verses. 

Genesis One is a prophecy. The sacred author describes the Earth just prior to God changing it's surface in the miraculous light event. The light event is a physical and phenomenal manifestation of God's power, election, mercy, love. God enacts an event in direct relation to the Earth via the Spirit. God and the Earth came face to face and as Earth revolved God was like the Sun, miraculously stimulating it in the events described.  If you were there to see you would see the Earth lit up and the atmosphere bursting forth from the waters. God sent forth the Spirit and transfigured the face of the Earth. This happened just prior to the Earth being locked into an inverse square gravitational regime with the Sun, which is described later in the narrative as the fourth day. 

Monday, February 25, 2019

Genesis Series: Darkness of Genesis 1:2

In a beginning, God had created the form Heaven and the form Earth.  And when Earth existed as an astonishing-desert, with darkness over a face of abyss . . . 
"Darkness was upon the face of the deep." A new source for fables and most impious imaginations if one distorts the sense of these words at the will of one’s fancies. By “darkness” these wicked men do not understand what is meant in reality—air not illumined, the shadow produced by the interposition of a body, or finally a place for some reason deprived of light. [. . .]The word is simple and within the comprehension of all. [. . .] But reason asks, was darkness created with the world? Is it older than light? Why in spite of its inferiority has it preceded it? Darkness, we reply, did not exist in essence; it is a condition produced in the air by the withdrawal of light. (Saint Basil, Hexaemeron, Homily II) 
What is Darkness?

Darkness lacks form and so refers to a concept.  Darkness is a brainwork. In the above quote, this is what Saint Basil was trying to get at. Since darkness is a concept it needs to be defined. Start by saying darkness is a relation of your eyes with all objects of the universe mediated by a fundamental subatomic object from which atoms derive their form, and by which atoms consummate light events and gravity/inertia in relation to all others.  An atom is literally a convergence of zillions of these fundamental subatomic objects which have unique properties and are probably liken to a double stranded thread.  Atoms constantly impinge upon these fundamental subatomic objects, in a torsion, at various frequencies, and in this we have basic action and reaction events.  When atoms or molecules of one's eyes receive certain frequencies from exterior objects the brain relates what we call darkness. Darkness resolves to a lack of certain frequencies which the eyes and brain can utilize in image. Darkness is concept conceived by Man.

In the Sacred Script, this concept is used to describe the object called Earth. In relation to the object called Earth is this relation called darkness. God did not create darkness. Darkness does not exist. Darkness has no nature. We can all go home and sleep well knowing that this word does not refer to some primeval entity, a mythical object, a fallen angel or Hell. Darkness could be used as a figurative concept to refer to other concepts such as evil or disorder, or a weak connection in the mind, etc. Yet here I have firmly established over the course of previous articles that the second verse of Genesis 1 refers to the astronomical object Earth. The sacred author saw the Earth. The Earth is the subject of the sentence. In Gen 1:2 use of the word darkness is not figurative, philosophic, mythical or even theological it is rather descriptive. The sacred author is describing the Earth as he saw it in a vision induced by God, just prior to the main light-event. If you want to read a philosophy or myth or scientific theory or theology or figurative language into this word then in my opinion you depart from the intention of the sacred author which is also the intention of God.

Strictly speaking there is no darkness only lower frequencies that the human eye cannot relay to the brain. If our eyes and brains utilized all frequencies we would literally be blinded by white light.  Mother Nature does not care what mode of frequencies your eyes and brain can use. She just keeps signaling at all frequencies from all atoms by way of these fundamental subatomic objects interconnecting all atoms.   

No matter where one looks the atoms of our eyes and entire body are being signaled at various frequencies. Light phenomenon is a constant occurrence. Light is a two way phenomenon: to and from all atoms, just as described by Newton's and Einstein's c squared concept. Atoms are constantly torquing the mediators at various frequencies. There is no real atom that is not giving and receiving a torsion signal via the physical mediators of light. Darkness resolves to a lack of certain frequencies stimulating your eyes. It is a subjective and artificial concept. Man made it up. God did not create darkness and the sacred author names it in Genesis 1 to help establish a context for the events happening.


Darkness in Genesis 1:2

In the Genesis 1:2 context, darkness is coupled to a preposition denoting spatial relations.  In Hebrew the word is 'al , and can be translated to English as 'over', 'upon', 'against', and so on.  Only darkness is not an object it is a concept. Darkness is not literally over, upon, against, the surface of the Earth, but while reading we simply reify (treat a concept as if an object) darkness and perform a contextual grammatical analysis and so understand that this is simply a concept.  Put two and two together and the sacred author is clearly referring to Earth and outer space contouring the surface of the Earth, so to speak.      


The sacred author was not describing the Earth from her surface, he was rather describing the Earth and surroundings from a bird's as if from a bird's eye view as if from outer space.  
The sacred author was mystically looking at the Earth and her surroundings and described it as dark.  No Sun was lighting up her surface as of yet.  

My Interpretive Theory of Darkness in Gen 1:2

The darkness concept in Gen 1:2 is fairly simple. I assume the sacred author experienced a prophetic 3D movie of the events he later described in his Script by Divine Inspiration. He looked at the Earth, saw it's Form as if orbiting her in space. He noticed a few surface features. But it was dark.  No Sun or star was lighting up her surface as of yet.  This implies that Earth was roaming somewhere in interstellar space and it also necessarily implies that it was cold and inactive.  If there were activity happening on the Earth he would have been able to see it just like we can see our cities lit up by satellites.    


The sacred author is explaining the face of the Earth as if seeing it from outer space. It is dark.  End of story. It is a very simple word just as Saint Basil said. It can be comprehended by all. Earth is dark and is contoured so to speak, by the darkness of space. Once you realize the sacred author was experiencing a prophetic 3D movie the descriptions are easy to visualize. Just imagine yourself in place of the sacred author.

Earth's Location


I believe God showed the sacred author the Earth as it was moving between stars. The Earth’s surface was at the time not stimulated as it is now closer to the Sun. Back then the Earth was swinging around the galactic core on a course near the Sun. She was not yet near the Sun when God first sent forth the Spirit and transformed her surface. So perhaps the sacred author saw Earth’s shape, and some surface features, but at first impression the surface may have been a bit dim by lack the full range of perceptible frequencies coming from the Earth. Blessed Anne Catherine Emmerich had a vision similar to the sacred author's and she describes the Earth as a ‘dark globe’. It was a dark star or black dwarf moving between stars i.e. interstellar space. In any case he clearly saw a shape and some surface features since Earth was miraculously spotlighted by the Presence of the Spirit.

In the fourth Divine Day, the God of power and of might moves the Earth into a locked system (an inverse square regime) with the Sun, and He, that is God moved the Moon in a system with the Earth so that these may signal at frequencies in a visible range.  However the events of Genesis 1 begin beyond the Sun’s effect on the Earth. So perhaps the sacred author saw something like this:



Like I said in another post these pictures are not to be taken too literally. All I am trying to do is help place one in the mystical eyes of the sacred author. The Earth was between stars. There was darkness beyond her boundary, however the Spirit of God was emitted from Heaven by the Father and the Son. Make no mistake it all happened very fast.  The Spirit literally lit up Earth's surface seconds prior to the main event. Perhaps the Spirit had one side of the Earth lit up in a preferential direction connected up to the Heaven of God.  Like a ray of light or spotlight.

Imagine being given a side view of God in Heaven as if a star emitting a ray of light down on a dark planet. The light beam connecting God in Heaven to the Earth lighting up one side of the Earth represents the Spirit. The Spirit was present as the Mediator of God's Word. The Father and the Son transformed the face of the Earth via the Spirit who was sent so as to establish a Divine connection. This is crucial to understand.

Spirit of God paralleled with Darkness

Darkness over a face of abyss
Spirit of God oscillating over a face of the waters

In the well-known and well-studied parallel structure of the second verse darkness is set in contrast to the Spirit of God moving over Earth's surface. Spirit of God and darkness are not synonyms or even antonyms. They are contrasted since the sacred author saw the Spirit moving around Earth's boundary. The Spirit is the only object proximate to the Earth. There is just the Earth, and the Spirit moving around the Earth's surface. So perhaps the movements of the Spirit lit up a portion of the Earth’s face when the command is sent and the Spirit stimulates the entire surface to erupt or expand out coinciding with a glow in the dark:

For the Spirit being one, and holding the place of light, was between the water and the Heaven, (Theophilus ad Autolycus, Genesis Commentary)
In the prophecy the Spirit is the go between God in Heaven and the Earth. The Spirit is there awaiting the command to stimulate the surface. Prior to the light-event God sent the Spirit to establish a singular unprecedented connection between God and the Earth.  

Thursday, February 21, 2019

Genesis Series: Tōhû wābōhû

Tōhû wābōhû is one of my favorite words of the entire Bible. It is wrapped in the mystique of the ages.

The Earth was what???  In this article I will first share a list of translations, then I will share my translation and unique interpretation.  

Translations


Latin Versions and Derivatives:


inanis et vacua (Vulgate)
void and empty (Douay Rheims)
empty and unoccupied (CPDV)
idel ond æmti (AElfric, Old Anglo-Saxon)
idol and void (Wycliffe)

Greek Versions and Derivatives:

aoratoj kai akatskeuastoj --- invisible and unformed (LXX w/ literal Eng trans.)
kenwma kai ouqen --- empty and nothing (Aquila)
qen kai ouqen --- nothing and nothing (Theodotion)
argon kai adiakriton --- unproductive and indistinguishable (Symmachus)
unsightly and unfinished (Brenton's English Septuagint)

Hebrew Derivatives:


chaos and vacancy (Hebrew Interlinear CHES 2.0 Version)
formless and void (NASB)
formless void (NJB)
formless wasteland (NAB Vatican Version)
without shape and empty (NET)
waste and void (Young's Literal)
without form and void (KJV & RSV)
formless and empty (WEB)

Foreign Language Bibles:

desordenada y vacia (Spanish, La Santa Biblia)
vide et deserte (French, La Sainte Bible)
afluniaidd a gwag (Welsh Bible)

Scholars:

astonishingly empty (Rashi)
completely empty (Rashbam)
empty waste (Ibn Ezra)
completely prime matter (Ramban)
desert waste (Claude Westermann)
haltos et gestaltos (Gorg)
contingent potentiality in a potentiality of being (Fabre d'Olivet)
hodgepodge (Jack Sasson)
mish-mash (William P. Brown suggestion)
welter and waste (Robert Alter)
chaos and watery chaos (Albright)
uninhabitable and unproductive (absence of fauna and flora: Roberto Ouro)
desert-like and empty or desolate and uninhabited (Tsumura)

Scholarly Notes:

"barrenness of the earth before anything grew on it" (N.H. Tur Sinai)

"a state of confused matter ... with no differentiation or organization" (U. Cassuto)

Targum Neof according to G. Anderson: "This text first reproduces the Aramaic equivalent of the Hebrew pair tohu wabohu and then interprets them. The first term, tohu, is interpreted to mean absence of faunal life; the second term, bohu, the absence of floral life." (from 'The Interpretation of Genesis 1 in the Targums', CBQ, 1990 p. 23)

My Translation:

astonishing-desert

Some Remarks on Translations

I am in strong opposition to translation rendering 'formless' or 'without form' or 'shapeless' or 'without shape'. These translations are oxymora. They are influenced by outmoded Aristotelian and Scholastic philosophies. They are fodder for troubled philosophers and opium induced drunks. The subject of the verse, the Earth, is a noun of reality. It is an object, an astronomical object. By definition it has form or shape. The Earth had a form long before the main light-event.  In supernatural vision, the prophet saw at an object that has a form. In this same vein I am opposed to the translations which include 'invisible' or 'nothing' or 'void'. Again the prophet saw an astronomical object so these would be non-nonsensical.

I am also opposed to the philosophical translations that suggest this verse refers to prime matter or any sort of philosophical translation. Sacred authors and prophets do not fop around with philosophy. A prime matter translation and interpretation destroys the context. What is prime matter? Define prime matter ________. Do you really think the ancient Hebrew had any notion of prime matter or saw prime matter? Does prime matter have a surface of waters?

I am also strongly opposed to the 'chaos' or 'Chaoskampf" translations and interpretations. These associate Genesis 1 with the Ancient Near Eastern myths. They read a struggle against evil into the Text. The holy author inspired by the Holy Spirit himself could not possibly be influenced by pagan creation myths.

And I am against the idea that this verse directly refers to Hell or fallen angels.  No stretch of the imagination could possibly see these in this verse since the Earth is described with surface features.

I do tend to favor the abiotic translations and interpretations. The Earth that the sacred author describes is obviously without living entities whether fauna or flora or microorganisms. These are narrated as coming into form within the light-event. But this line of thought doesn't resolve the mystique of the word. What exactly did the sacred author see and then describe? How can one reconcile the notions of desert, desolation, aridity, idleness, emptiness, etc with that of a water covered surface? Can one make sense of this seeming contradiction? I think one can.

Earth was and still is a very old inactive dark star or rogue planet that naturally transitioned for countless years prior to the main event prophetically recorded in Genesis 1.  Planets are cooling and compressing stars with vast histories. The object that the prophet saw and later described was what is perhaps what we could call an 'ice planet' or 'ice world'. The Earth was slumbering in cold interstellar space away from newer active stars. She was not far from the newer Sun and yet not yet orbiting the Sun. Her surface was icy H20 and volatiles with ancient subsurface liquid oceans (or abysses). The subsurface abysses were heated by her hot core that stimulated mantle and crust. Like Antarctica she was dry and arid yet still had an immense water supply. Her surface was idle and barren. The Spirit was about to stimulate her surface in the light-event. But upon first impression, the prophet was mystified by what he saw. This is what led him to trace and utter the Hebrew word wrapped in the mystique of the ages:

tōhû wābōhû


A Tōhû wābōhû Thought Experiment

Imagine you are an inhabitant of the Middle East.  You live about four thousand years ago. You've never seen an image captured by the space crafts in your life. But you have had the fortune of travelling all around the Middle East. You are familiar with all sorts of terrain. You've seen the lush pastures and vines of the Fertile Crescent but you have also been to the Arabian Peninsula and explored the edges of the Arabian Desert. You've seen the dread dunes of the Rub' al Khali. Maybe you've even seen or heard of the white deserts of Egypt. But your heart is in the Holy Land. You are a Hebrew. You speak a primitive mode of the Hebrew tongue and of course you love your God who led you out of Egypt.

One night you go to sleep. While asleep instead of dreaming a dream of fragmented memories you experience a vivid movie in which you seem to be a part of!!! The first frame of the movie appears as something like this:


the Jovian Moon Ganymede

What would be your first impression? How would you first describe this object in your own tongue and in accord with your own experiences? Perhaps it would remind you something like the Moon, yet given your location and time is there even a word to describe something like this? What would you write about it?

If you have read some of this blog you know I am biased toward a prophetic interpretation of Genesis 1. I assume the sacred author had a vision, of course stimulated by God. Gen 1:2 is his basic description of the first frame of his prophetic 3D movie. Either in retrospect or while experiencing the movie he realized that the object he was looking at was Earth. I assume at least in the beginning of his vision on the first Divine Day, he saw Earth from a bird's eye view and described what he saw.

I don't want anyone to take the above image too literally. I chose Ganymede as a model for the thought experiment. Ganymede is a good model since it has little or no atmosphere as well as a surface of icy H2O and silicate rock. It is also thought that a salt water ocean exists under the surface layers of ice water. Plus Ganymede is perhaps an old dark star like Earth.  Maybe Ganymede is something like the Earth that the sacred author first saw in his prophetic movie. He may have had a closer view brought into focus as the vision unfolded. Recall of the God induced vision led him to pen the famous tōhû wābōhû description.

My interpretive theory for the tōhû wābōhû concept is fairly simple. The Earth that the sacred author saw reminded him of a desert or wasteland. Only for him this was no ordinary desert terrain. For him deserts were regions of land with boundaries relating them to other terrains. But the wasteland that the Genesis 1 prophet saw had no boundaries other than the boundary of the entire object facing him. The entire face appeared bare, dry, without rain (no atmosphere), lifeless, inactive, uninhabited, and so on and so forth. And so he conceptualized an ultimate wasteland, a wasteland to end all wastelands, a strange wasteland. To him the Earth that he saw was a surreal desert, a super-desert, since he had no concept of an entire planetary surface barren before his eyes, perhaps excepting the Moon, but even in comparison to the Moon this was even vivid and strange.  And of course he understood the difference between the Earth and Moon.

The ancient Hebrew has a manner of repeating a word so as to denote intensity or emphasis. An example of this is taken from Genesis 3:16. God uses the word rabah twice in succession to denote intensity:

Increasing I increase your labor pains, etc.

Word repetitions or so called 'figures of repetition' are not exclusive to ancient Hebrew tongue, they are common to many languages. In fact there is a catalog of word repetitions in Greek. Figures of repetition are employed to stimulate emphasis, clarity, amplification or emotions. The Genesis 1 author did something similar only he got a little creative. He provokingly added a manner of mystique to his amplifier by changing the first letter and connecting via the Hebrew letter 'waw'.

Tohu can refer to a desert or a wasteland (see Tsumura: The Earth and Waters in Genesis 1 & 2: A Linguistic Investigation). The connected word bohu is a spontaneous intensifier of the word tohu. Because of the strangeness of the object recalled from the vision the sacred author decided to invent the new word bohu so as to intensify and even mystify the referent of tohu. Instead of simply duplicating tohu so as to intensify, he decided to get a little creative and may I say stylish, by changing a letter and connecting via the waw letter. So instead of tohu tohu we are given tōhû wābōhû. The modified intensifier that is tōhû wābōhû  used only two other times in all of extant literature (beyond Sacred Scripture).

This word discloses a mystic experience. One can almost feel the emotion evoked from the very word he invented.  What he saw was wondrous and momentous.  And so it is my theory that the sacred author invented the word in response to his prophetic vision. The word is later adopted by Jeremiah and Isaiah for use in their prophecies. Tōhû wābōhû or tohu and bohu paralleled in the same verse is exclusively used in Hebrew Prophecies. It is a prophetic word.

The referent of tohu wa-bohu is the whole surface of the ancient Earth. In the 'structure' of the second verse, Earth and tohu wabohu have no parallel whereas waters is paralleled to abyss, and darkness is paralleled with Spirit of God.

And when Earth was an astonishing-desert, and darkness over --- a face of abyss, and the Spirit of God oscillating over --- a face of waters.  
Tohu wabohu is a description of the entire object facing the sacred author in the prophetic movie. The Earth first appeared to be a desert world. The sacred author could have simply stated: And when Earth was an astonishing-desert. Tōhû wābōhû is the sacred author's name of the object we call Earth which grammatically speaking is the subject Earth of this sentence. It is the head descriptor or main descriptor of the Earth. The paralleled second and third clauses: "Darkness over a face of abyss and the Spirit of God oscillating over the face of the waters" modify and add additional information to the main descriptive word: tōhû wābōhû and of course the main subject Earth.

I translate tohu wabohu as astonishing-desert or astonishing-wasteland in honor of Rashi's idea:

The word תֹהוּ is an expression of astonishment and desolation that a person wonders and is astonished at the emptiness therein. (Rashi Commentaries)
Rashi's idea fits in with my prophetic assumption. The sacred author was astonished by what he saw. The Hebrew word tōhû wābōhû has wrapped up in it all the excitement and strangeness of seeing an object that has never been seen before. This is why it is a unique wonder of a word. I think Rashi has a good attitude toward this word. In the midst of all the solemnity and gravity read into this story I suggest there was a little playfulness and creativity happening in the mind of this Middle Eastern child of God when he wrote. This suggestion fits the context. The miraculous transformation of the Earth described in this story is a joyful occasion. It must have been for a prophet an elating as well as majestic experience to see it happen in a prophetic state. He even experienced the satisfaction of God described in "And God saw that is was good!"  So instead of going with desert wasteland, I went with astonishing-desert or astonishing-wasteland. Other ideas could be ultimate-desert or super desert.

These translation are concrete and I prefer it this way. They offer the reader an opportunity to visualize the setting. But there is a problem with this translation and interpretation. Scholar R. Gilboa raises the issue:

Suggestions for tohu as ‘desert’ (a geographical term often used for arid and uninhabited land OED) are implausible even impossible since we are told that everything is covered with waters. (p. 242, Intercourses in the Book of Genesis)
Gilboa seems to be biased toward a mythical chaos interpretation but this is a reasonable point.  We have a bit of an enigma here.  I would answer his valid objection by stating the ancient Earth could have been thought of a desert while covered with waters. This is what everyone should want to know. How is this possible? What was the Earth when the Spirit was sent forth so as to stimulate it? The sacred author knew that there was a water supply on the Earth's surface and under the surface. He saw what he figured were waters erupt from the surface, react, and wrap around into the the first essential modern atmosphere. Then he saw that God moved the Earth close to the Sun so as to receive her light.

But before these courses of events happened the Earth was moving between stars. She was located far enough away from younger active stars so that her surface waters were not stimulated to liquid. Her surface was 'flooded' over with waters, but the waters were perhaps frozen. And maybe the waters in her subsurface remained liquid via the stimulation of her hot core. But on the outside she was an idle ice world. An ice world can be thought of and described as a desert or a wasteland especially to an ancient Middle Easterner who has never seen one before!

Now you may ask what is the Earth? What was her history prior to the Divine phenomena recorded in Genesis 1? How did she get her water supply? I've already said many times in previous articles that I hold to the assumption that the Earth is an old dark star or rogue planet. I'm not a follower of the solar nebular hypothesis and the Big-Bang with its time constraint. I think the Earth naturally transitioned to her long black dwarf phase from a young active phase such as our Sun. She is supposed to have begun as a star magnitudes larger than our Sun. She was fit to fuse and compress a sold iron core. Prior to her stimulation and transfiguration with God she cooled to a phase where she may have synthesized H & O to H2O at her outer layers not to mention many other crystals, chemicals, compounds and so on. Or she may have assimilated H2O by swinging through dense interstellar medium in her galactic rotation or even by crossing paths with other stars such as TW Hydrae which has an abundant water supply in its formation disk.  And like I said before regardless of what I think about the Earth prior to the main event in Genesis it is clearly described as an astronomical object with surface features as we will further see.  So the only other choices we have other than the above is 


1.  God simply created this astronomical object ex nihilo which He could have done but did not need to since he had gazillions of rogue planets to choose from

2.  It was a planet formed in a primeval nebula of another star not our Sun and got thrown out of orbit, wandering through interstellar space like a rogue. 

But I think planets could very well be old cool stars. Some of these are captured or guided into orbit of newer active stars via their heliospheres. Once they are guided in they swing around the mother star by the fundamental subatomic object connecting as well as constituting all the atoms of the Universe.  But our planet was not captured. It was placed in orbit around the Sun by God on the fourth Divine day in the course it's transfiguration that God initiated perhaps just beyond the Sun's heliosphere.

The beauty of the story is that our history began with God and Heaven and the Earth, alone beyond the Sun's influence. Everything about the Earth as it now is: is unique. The Earth is elect, meaning God chose it out of gazillions. He made a connection with it by emitting the Spirit, and he renewed her face!

Tōhû wābōhû serves as a mystic first description of Earth as the sacred author saw her prior to the miraculous light event enacted by God via the missive Spirit.  

Sunday, February 17, 2019

Genesis Series: Universe and Matter in Genesis 1?

Universe and Matter?

Some choose to interpret the universe and matter into the first two verses of Genesis 1. If they choose this route they are tasked with convincing the reader that God and the sacred author used figurative language in this context, e.g. Earth figuratively alludes to matter. They are also tasked with defining the key words universe and matter in no uncertain terms. Then they are tasked with convincing the reader that their definitions of the key words universe and matter is what God and the sacred author directly intended to communicate to the reader via the figures they chose. For example you will have to explain how the sacred author knew your definition of matter's creation ex nihilo well enough to describe it using figures of speech. Did the sacred author see matter, figure it as the Earth, and then describe it as a tohu wabohu? Did the sacred author go to school in Greece, learn Aristotle's concepts of matter and decide to put it in his own words? Is it even possible that the sacred author referred to matter via the word 'Earth'???

Similar with those commentators who wish to adopt models of modern physics and assume them to the Sacred Text. Convince me, that the sacred author saw the Big-Bang or studied general and special relativity as well as quantum mechanics at Oxford. Convince me that the sacred author saw the Higg's Boson field and particle and decided to represent it with the words Earth and tōhû wābōhû.

History of Matter Interpretations


In his survey of Genesis 1 translations and interpretations through the ages Jaki begins with the ancient Jewish sages who lived after the Hellenistic invasion of the Middle East. He mentions:

Some took the tohu and bohu as the prime matter from which light and darkness were respectively created. (Jaki, Stanley J. Genesis Through the Ages, Chapter 1: Genesis 1 and Jewish Sages, p. 37)
Some Jewish sages were likely influenced by Grecian notions of matter perhaps Aristotle's. Aristotle's vague matter concept was linked to his change of substance and form concepts. These terms were used rather ambiguously. But the problem with this line of interpretation of that the concept 'matter' was not something the ancient Hebrew author conceived of. He lived well before Aristotle and the Grecian philosophers. This alone should rule out the matter interpretation of Gen 1:2. Do you really think the ancient Hebrew sacred author and possible prophet knew of the Greek concepts of matter? If so which Greek philosopher did he follow? Aristotle or Democritus? Is it even possible to retain intellectual honesty when travelling down this foreign interpretive path?

Through history the matter interpretation continues to appear. Some Christians have adopted the matter interpretation. Saint Basil, a Church Father from the 4th century was up in arms concerning the matter interpretation:

But the corrupters of the truth, who, incapable of submitting their reason to Holy Scripture, distort at will the meaning of the Holy Scriptures, pretend that these words mean matter. For it is matter, they say, which from its nature is without form and invisible,—being by the conditions of its existence without quality and without form and figure. (Basil Hexaemeron, Homily II)
My favorite example of the sloppy matter interpretation is taken from the drunken-opium induced proto-god of modern cosmology also known as Edgar Allan Poe. After his wife died Poe entered into a severe depression and penned a delusional book called Eureka: A Prose Poem. In this book he used a sloppy translation of Gen 1:2, in particular tōhû wābōhû to help him dream up a primitive version of the Big-Bang model:
We have attained a point where only Intuition can aid us: — but now let me recur to the idea which I have already suggested as that alone which we can properly entertain of intuition. It is but the conviction arising from those inductions or deductions of which the processes are so shadowy as to escape our consciousness, elude our reason, or defy our capacity of expression. With this understanding, I now assert — that an intuition altogether irresistible, although inexpressible, forces me to the conclusion that what God originally created — that that Matter which, by dint of his Volition, he first made from his Spirit, or from Nihility, could have been nothing but Matter in its utmost conceivable state of — what? — of Simplicity? 
Let us now endeavor to conceive what Matter must be, when, or if, in its absolute extreme of Simplicity. Here the Reason flies at once to Imparticularity — to a particle — to one particle — a particle of one kind — of one character — of one nature — of one size — of one form — a particle, therefore, “without form and void” — a particle positively a particle at all points — a particle absolutely unique, individual, undivided, and not indivisible only because He who created it, by dint of his Will, can by an infinitely less energetic exercise of the same Will, as a matter of course, divide it. (Taken from Section 02)
It is good to note that Poe preceded LeMaitre's primeval atom hypothesis by about eighty years. But notice how ridiculously Poe contradicts himself in the same sentence. He speculates a discrete particle of one form and yet magically 'without form and void'! An object cannot both have a form and not have a form. By definition an object has form. All types of matter, whether the fundamental objects constituting as well as interconnecting all atoms and the atoms themselves this primal quality called FORM. And void refers to that which lacks form. So then did God disintegrate and then annihilate whatever it was that Earth refers to?

Poe got drunk, inhaled opium and fed off of bad translations. Poe's folly illustrates the faultiness of the 'formless', 'without form', 'shapeless', 'without shape' and 'void' translations of the Hebrew tōhû wābōhû. These translations are heavily influenced by outdated Aristotelian and Scholastic philosophical notions. Philosophic notions such as matter and form and substance have no place in Genesis 1.

In our times commentators continue to read space and matter into the first verses of the great Genesis 1. Some examples include:

Rev. John F. McCarthy: On the plain and superficial level, the earth (haarets) in verse 1 means the land inhabited by man, whether it be thought of as a globe, a disk, or just a territory with as yet unknown borders. On the technical literal level it seems to mean primal matter as the ground of all future corporeal beings.

in another place
Taking, then, a model of modern physics, we can interpret the text as saying that, on the most elementary subatomic level, the "earth" spoken of here is the primal matter which was created as the "ground" of all more organized matter and which was infinitesimal, unstructured, minimally informed, and in a totally fluid state. (see his page:http://www.rtforum.org/)

McCarthy supports the concordist school of interpretation and it seems that he manipulates words like a magician.  In one verse we are shifting from Earth to ground to matter to the subatomic level.  Similarly some misguided interpreters are packing into a single word from Earth to clay to homonids to male and female gametes in their desperation to make Genesis 2 conform to modern theories of evolution.

Next,      

Pastor Bill Randles: The first verse of the Bible, is a summation of all that exists, for there is only Creator and creation. The infinite, personal, almighty, and Holy God made the heavens, (Space) and the Earth, (Matter) in the beginning, (Time). [...] The text simply tells us that when God created matter, it was originally in a formless state, waiting for his creative hand to give shape to it. Our physical world was created first in a formless state, and also in a state of darkness, for it pleased God to shape , and energize the world in later stages of Creation. (see his page:http://billrandles.wordpress.com/2013/05/26/creation-ex-nihilo-genesis-1-pt-2/)

So Heaven refers to space and Earth to matter. Space and matter are concepts. God doesn't create concepts, He creates objects. Created objects relate via objects (mediators) and we conceptualize their relations.

Lakeside Ministries: "WITHOUT FORM AND VOID" [. . .] THE ESSENTIAL MEANING, THEREFORE, IS: "In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth (or SPACE and MATTER), and the matter so created was at first unformed and uninhabited." [. . .] The created cosmos, as discussed earlier, was a tri-universe of TIME, SPACE, and MATTER. Initially there were no stars or planets, only the basic matter component of the space-matter-time continuum. The elements that were to be formed into the planet Earth were at first only elements, not yet formed but nevertheless comprising the basic matter- the "DUST" of the earth. (reference:http://lakesideministries.com/1stCovenant/Genesis/04_GenSect0102_Creation_Itself.htm)

So the Middle Eastern Hebrew author conveniently conceived of a tri-universe of Time, Space and Matter---all Western concepts.

Some few have even tried to fit the Big-Bang into the first three verses (e.g. Gerald Schroeder). The Earth refers to the universe or prime matter (whatever that is), tohu and bohu refers to the state of prime matter, the darkness over faces of waters refers to space-time, the Spirit is moving over space-time and then Bang! Flash! There is light. Out go the discrete photon particles which miraculously stretch as waves. About 13.8 billion years later the scientists detect them with their grand technology and some interpreters proclaim to the world that Genesis 1 was always right after all!!! We have proof in the Cosmic Microwave Background radiation. And so on. Apparently the sacred author studied mathematical physics and knew that relativity breaks down at the quantum level. He was a follower of Lemaitre, Einstein, Hubble, and the gang. Maybe he built a satellite. Or perhaps he had a vision of the Big-Bang. What do you think?

Personal intentions aside, I think that those who read in prime matter or Big-Bang in the second verse of Genesis join the ranks of drunks, charlatans and frauds. There is no justification for reading the creation of matter into the first sequence of Genesis 1 period. This is an unsound interpretation. Sober faith-filled minds snub their noses at these ridiculous interpretations. They betray a lack of humility and respect for the Sacred Script which implies respect for God and the sacred author who worked together in a mystical relationship as joint authors.


For whatever reason, from time immemorial, probably out of misguided pride or weakness of mind, men try to wed Genesis 1 to the physics and/or philosophy of the day. Or they get delusional. Instead of coming up with creative solutions with what has been given in the Text they get delusions of grandeur. Of course there are also those at the other end of the spectrum who sell out completely on Faith.

Conclusion of the Above

Throughout history matter has been ill-defined. It is a joke of a word. People, including scientists, use it for anything and everything. The sacred author could have cared less about matter. To imagine the sacred author thought of or saw the creation of what would have been to him unknown material and then describe it using figures is an unacceptable stretch of the imagination.

Instead, what is clear is that an astronomical object called Earth is the important object to the sacred author since this is the location where all the supernatural events that he relates take place. And it is important to us since we are conceived and born on Earth, live on Earth and will certainly die on Earth.  Christians also believe that God will create a New Earth after the Resurrection and Last Judgment.

A central theme of Genesis 1 is the Earth. Earth is elect, chosen by God.  This does not imply that the Earth is the center of the universe. This was read into the Text by the Greek influenced ancients. Genesis 1 has nothing to do with physics or philosophy, Greeks or ANE myths, moderns or ancients, believers or atheists, medievals or post-Moderns, rabbis or priests, Popes or gurus, creation ex nihilo or an eternal universe, Big-Bang or the cosmological principle. Genesis 1 has everything to do with a miraculous course of events that God, in the past, wrought in relation to Earth and showed to the sacred author who in-errantly recorded them in the third person. That is all.

The Definition of Universe and Matter

I now want to share a clear definition of universe and matter that I have inherited in order to confirm that there is no possible way the sacred author could be referring to these in the first and second verse of the Bible.

Universe is a concept, to be more precise an abstract concept.  Concept refers to a relation between two or more objects worked out by the brain.  Modify concept to a higher order mode and one has a nest of objects and/or concepts together in abstraction. Universe is an abstract binary conceptual system that relates space and matter.  Matter is quite simply a conceptual nest of all existing objects, i.e. all that which has form.  For example, atoms, stars, trees, and so on.  Space relates lack of form, in other words a static distance between all existing objects.  I would guess that an ancient got sick of saying, "All the trees, and all the hills and the seas, and all the men, women, and children, and all the stars, and space and the aether, etc." So he came up with the bright idea now called Universe or Cosmos. Universe lacks From, this name resolves to a high order abstraction.

Again, space is a sheer concept that refers to nothing in existence. It is all 'where' and no 'what'. Space is distance.  Space does not have form and neither does time. Objects do not occupy space or time. We imagine space and time, and then hopefully define these words but objects are just there, they cannot be defined.

Earth

The events of Genesis 1 are frames of the Universal Movie. And yet they were not a result of Mother Nature, but of God emitting His Spirit and supernaturally transforming the face of the Earth in what I simply call the light-event. And he initiated an exclusive relationship with the Earth that is not found among all the stars of the universe. God accomplished the impossible.

The subject of Gen 1:2 is planet Earth. The Earth of the second verse is not a figure referring to matter or anything else other than the ancient astronomical object under our feet. The second verse picks up with the Earth of the first verse. She is the new subject and the sacred author adds additional information and modification concerning her.

My loose speculation is that the Earth of the first verse and second verse is an old dark star that naturally transitioned up to the time when the Spirit was emitted. The assumption that the Earth is the cinder of what was once a star has rarely been suggested through history but it is much more reasonable than the solar nebular assumption. Perhaps it is even suggested in this lofty sequence from the Book of Job. God speaks to Job:

Where were you when I laid the foundation of the Earth?
Tell me, if you possess understanding!
Who set its measurements – if you know –
or who stretched a measuring line across it?
​​​​​​​On what were its bases set,
or who laid its cornerstone –
​​​​​​​when the morning stars sang in chorus,
and all the sons of God shouted for joy? (NET)

The formation of the Earth seems to be associated with a time of morning stars perhaps referring to the first stars.

Some modern philosophers and physicists, one of whom is Anthony J. Abruzzo have gone as far as to suggest that the Earth is an old dark star that has existed for billions of years, longer than the supposed age of the Universe in modern physical cosmology. This idea makes more sense to me, and fits in better with an interpretation of Genesis 1.  Even G.K. Chesterton made a strange and somewhat mystical allusion to this idea that Earth is a star:

If we once realize all this earth as it is, we should find ourselves in a land of miracles: we shall discover a new planet at the moment that we discover our own. Among all the strange things that men have forgotten, the most universal and catastrophic lapse of memory is that by which they have forgotten that they are living on a star.
---G.K. Chesterton, From The Defendent

In any case sacred author sets up his story perhaps countless years after creation ex nihilo at the previously stated object, the Earth. He did not necessarily have to know anything about Earth's prior history. It was just there in his vision, and he was left to describe it in the Script, generally, as it was just prior to the light-event.

This is my basic interpretive theory to help shed light on the first and second verses of Genesis 1. In the second verse the sacred author speaks of the Earth as an evident object of anterior creation. What he knew of the Earth's history prior to what he was shown is a moot point. All he stated was that God had created a definite object he traced as Earth. I think the sacred author saw the Earth in a vision from a bird's eye view as if orbiting her like a satellite. He saw her face like we see the face of the Moon from Earth, only he had a closer view. The word he chose to describe the full view of her face was the mystic tōhû wābōhû.

Informal Intro to Genesis 1:2

There are all sorts of talk about the grammar of the second verse and how it fits into sequence of the first three verses e.g. disjunctive clause, circumstantial clause, parenthetical clause. Perhaps the insight that circumscribes all the grammar talk is the suggestion by Westermann that the second verse is a ‘this and not yet that’ description. The Earth is described as she appeared just prior to the main event or the light-event as I call it. 


The sacred author was not given a prophetic movie of the Earth's entire history from when she first formed, I assume like all stars do, gravitation-ally from an interstellar cloud with perhaps some trigger event. Instead he was given a some frames of the Earth just prior to God entering the movie. God was about to manifest Himself by transfiguring the Earth via the missive Spirit. The Spirit was primed to receive God's commands and work the Earth in the cold darkness of interstellar space. It was a very exciting time, and the prophet was fortunate to have been given sight of this great miracle, a miracle so great that only little children of the Holy Father can believe it.

The Earth was at that time not unlike other planets or moons.   An old dark star metamorphosed from its younger phase of fusion, compression, crystallization and chemical reaction.  She probably passed through several dense interstellar clouds by which atomic elements and molecules diversified her makeup. The elements of her essence synthesized and solidified. As she cooled she probably synthesized H2O helping form her crust or perhaps assimilated some of her H2O from a dense interstellar medium for water is abundant between stars.

Earth was a wandering star. In its latter stages of development the Earth may have even orbited a younger star besides the Sun. But when God initiated the first described event of our Genesis 1 story the Earth was moving about halfway out from the galactic core in the vicinity of a newer star called by the sacred author the "greater light", the Sun. After God forms the atmosphere, He will move the Earth in a gravitational lock with the Sun later in the story, on the fourth Divine day. He will also place the lesser light, the moon and the other planets of our solar system which he calls stars in close relation to Earth so they can be seen by us and used to keep times, on the same day.  


But when God was about to initiate the light-event the Earth had some sort of core, mantle, crust, a water supply and either no atmosphere or a thin atmosphere. And she was not a ball of chaos. She was slumbering in the cold darkness of space. Some of her surface froze over and she appeared as an astonishing-desert or wasteland. Perhaps she was an ice planet. Not a lot of activity was happening on her surface. There were no living entities. She was waiting to receive the stimulation of the Spirit and glow in the dark!

The seer saw her full face in a prophecy, was mystified and came up with a playful word to first describe her, namely: tōhû wābōhû. There are some excellent scholarly studies of this gem of a Hebrew word.